The Epstein scandal at MIT shows the moral bankruptcy of techno-elites

The MIT-Epstein debacle shows the prostitution of intellectual activity. Time for a radical agenda: close the Media Lab, disband Ted Talks and refuse tech billionaires money

As the world wakes up to the power of big tech, we get to hear belatedly of all the damage wrought by the digital giants. Most of these debates, alas, dont veer too far from the policy-oriented realms of economics or law. Now that the big technocracy wants to quash big tech, expect more such wonkery.


Recommended For You

Voicematic Annual

Get The World’s First Breakthrough AI Driven Voice Autoresponder and Voice Funnel Creator that helps you Automatically Track, Follow-Up and Manage Missed or Incoming Calls, without the need to pick up the phone!

Animaytor Diamond Personal | Ultimatum Video Creator

Animaytor Diamond Personal | Studio Quality 40 DONE-FOR-YOU Niche Templates with Image and Video, Powerpoint Style Videos, 1000 Transparent Images, 5000 Photos and Images, Customizable Video Scripts and Templates, 50 Borders, 60 Headers and Footers!


What, however, about the ideas that feed big tech? For one, we are no longer in 2009: Mark Zuckerbergs sophomoric musings on transparency or the global village impress very few.

And yet, for all the growing skepticism about Silicon Valley, many still believe that the digital revolution has a serious intellectual dimension, hashed out at conferences like Ted, online salons like, publications like Wired, and institutions like the MIT Media Lab. The ideas of the digerati might be wrong, they might be overly utopian, but, at least, they are sincere.

The Epstein scandal including the latest revelation that Epstein might have channeled up to $8m (some of it, apparently, on behalf of Bill Gates) to the MIT Media Lab, while its executives were fully aware of his problematic background has cast the digerati in a very different light. It has already led to the resignation of the labs director, Joi Ito.

This, however, is not only a story of individuals gone rogue. The ugly collective picture of the techno-elites that emerges from the Epstein scandal reveals them as a bunch of morally bankrupt opportunists. To treat their ideas as genuine but wrong is too generous; the only genuine thing about them is their fakeness. Big tech and its apologists do produce the big thoughts alas, mostly accidental byproducts of them chasing the big bucks.

It wasnt meant to be that way. Back in 1991, John Brockman the worlds most successful digital impresario, and, until recently, my literary agent was touting the emergence of the third culture that would finally replace the technophobic literary intellectuals with those coming from the world of science and technology. The emergence of the third culture introduces new modes of intellectual discourse and reaffirms the pre-eminence of America in the realm of important ideas, wrote Brockman in a much-discussed essay.

Brockman, who would later connect Epstein to dozens of world-famous scientists, most of them his clients, made it seem as if it were people like him who built this third culture out of their perceptive genius. The cardinal error of such analysis, however, lies in its tendency to mistake structural transformations of global capitalism for zeitgeisty trends in the history of ideas.

Thus, Brockmans new modes of intellectual discourse were mostly the result of technology companies moving away from large and soulless cold war military contracts and on to the world of funky personal computing. Apple, with Steve Jobs as its chief countercultural evangelist, needed the consumerist mysticism of the third culture; IBM and Hewlett-Packard, stuck in the 1950s mentality, did not. Likewise, the pre-eminence of America in the realm of important ideas was, above all, the outcome of its dominance in the economic and military realms, weakening the efforts of other countries to create their own vibrant alternatives to Hollywood or Silicon Valley.

There was no better original exponent of the third culture than Nicholas Negroponte, the founder of the MIT Media Lab and a new kind of applied intellectual, full of big ideas on technical subjects. The lab was ahead of its time in understanding that the industry and the government alike needed cooler, more interactive technology that was not provided by the traditional cold war contractors.

Everything else followed suit. Thus, Negroponte became a speaker at the very first Technology, Entertainment, Design conference (the famous Ted Talks) in 1984, which, a few decades later, emerged as the pre-eminent promoter of the third culture: no politics, no conflict, no ideology just science, technology, and pragmatic problem-solving. Ideas as a service, neatly packaged in 18-minute intellectual snacks.


Recommended For You

Social Robot - Supreme Edition

Social Robot - Supreme Edition

Curation Lab - One-Time Payment

Curation Lab is the ULTIMATE tool to curate high-quality content from multiple sources online while building passive traffic streams!

ShopMozo - Enterprise

DEAD SIMPLE 1-click cloud based Affiliate Store builder that uses the Power of Videos, SEO and Social Media to Automatically Add Affiliate Products from top E-Commerce giants


Joi Ito in 2009: Ito was to the third culture of the 2000s what Negroponte was to its 1980s version. Photograph: Alicia Canter/Alicia Canter (commissioned)

Third culture was a perfect shield for pursuing entrepreneurial activities under the banner of intellectualism. Infinite networking with billionaires but also models and Hollywood stars; instant funding by philanthropists and venture capitalists moving in the same circles; bestselling books tied to soaring speaking fees used as promotional materials for the authors more substantial commercial activities, often run out of academia.

That someone like Jeffrey Epstein would take advantage of these networks to whitewash his crimes was almost inevitable. In a world where books function as brand extensions and are never actually read, its quite easy for a rich and glamorous charlatan of Epsteins stature to fit in.

One of Brockmans persistent laments was that all the billionaire techies in his circle barely read any of the books published by his clients. Not surprisingly, his famed literary dinners held during the Ted Conference, they allowed Epstein (who kept Brockmans Edge Foundation on a retainer) to mingle with scientists and fellow billionaires were mostly empty of serious content.

As Brockman himself put it after one such dinner in 2004, last year we tried The Science Dinner. Everyone yawned. So this year, its back to the money-sex-power thing with The Billionaires Dinner. Was the money-sex-power thing that very potent new mode of intellectual discourse promised by the third culture? If so, wed rather pass.

In attendance at one such dinner, in 1999, was a young Japanese American by the name of Joi Ito; also present were Richard Saul Wurman, the original founder of the Ted Conference, Jeff Bezos, and, among all the other billionaires, Jeffrey Epstein. A godson of Timothy Leary and a college drop-out, Ito would eventually lead the Media Lab, interview Obama, write a popular technology book (another Brockman client), and join 20 different boards, including those of such prestigious institutions as the New York Times, the MacArthur Foundation, and the Knight Foundation.

Ito was to the third culture of the 2000s what Negroponte was to its 1980s version. Whereas Negroponte has always projected an aura of aristocracy and privilege coming from a very wealthy Greek family, he has recently prided himself on being on first-name terms with 80% of billionaires Ito is your typical startup disruptor, a disgruntled ex-manager of a nightclub in Japan, who, somehow, reinvented himself as a third culture intellectual.

However, much like at Brockmans billionaire dinners, theres not much content to be found in Itos work: for the most part, its just techno-blabbery mixed with a heavy dose of futuristic jargon. But it doesnt matter. Under the third culture, ideas serve, primarily, as door-openers. All that MIT cared about was that Itos ideas supported his networks, his fundraising skills, and his ability to get donors like Epstein to write fat checks.

Is it so surprising, then, that when a colleague cautioned Ito against meeting Epstein who used to list his interests as science and pussy Ito described him as really fascinating? Brockman, for all his realism about low intellectual standards of the tech community, also couldnt resist Epsteins charms, describing him, in an email to me, as extremely bright and interesting.

If the third culture is so much more sophisticated than its predecessors, how come most of its card-carrying members famed scientists-cum-brands, courtesy of the Brockman empire got caught up in the Epstein mess? Its not uncommon for intellectuals to serve as useful idiots to the rich and the powerful, but, under the third culture, this reads like a job requirement.

Are the costs of living with this culture eg the prostitution of intellectual activity at billionaire dinners worth it? And can we still trust what the leading intellectuals of the third culture actually have to say, given, also, what they have to sell?

The answers to these questions are self-evident. And yet, while its easy to attack the rotten apples such as Ito or Negroponte, a more radical transformative agenda should ask for more: close the Media Lab, disband the Ted Talks, refuse the money of tech billionaires, boycott agents like Brockman. Without such drastic changes, the powerful bullshit-industrial complex that is the third culture will continue unharmed, giving cover to the next Epstein.


Recommended For You

MaxDrive Enterprise

Host, Manage And Deliver Unlimited Files, Website Images, PDFs, Audios and Videos At Lightning Fast SPEED For Next 5 Years with No Monthly Fee


ContentLAB makes it easy to find, customize and publish relevant, high-impact content to multiple blogs, websites, and social media simultaneously… without the typical hassles of writing content from scratch or paying a writer to do it.

Pinflux 2 Elite Monthly

Pinflux is the most powerful automation application for Pinterest marketing. It automates all your repetitive tasks and saves you time.

  • Evgeny Morozov is a Guardian US columnist

Original Article : HERE ;

This post was curated & Posted using : RealSpecific

Thank you for taking the time to read our article.

Interested in building a blog or auto-blog like this one ? Or just want to order one ?  Join our "Blogging Tips Tricks and Resources Skype" Group and let's chat about it. 

Join "Blogging Tips Tricks and Resources Skype" HERE

Interested in Starting your own Roku TV Channel ? Or interested in learning how to build one ? Join our "Roku TV Channel Development" Skype Group and let's chat about it. 

Join "Roku TV Channel Development" HERE


If you enjoyed our content, we'd really appreciate some "love" with a share or two.

And ... Don't forget to have fun!



Pixielogo Pro

Pixielogo Pro offers more templates, more icons and monthly templates free of charge to continue creating good looking logos for you and your clients.

Trenzy Pro

Get this Breakthrough App That Harnesses The Power of Hot Trending Topics for NON-STOP Buyer Traffic in 3 Simple Clicks

MaxDrive Commercial

Host, Manage And Deliver Unlimited Files, Website Images, PDFs, Audios and Videos At Lightning Fast SPEED For Next 5 Years with No Monthly Fee

Leave a Reply